New Truck vs. Used Truck: How Your Rig Choice Affects Insurance Costs

Choosing between a brand-new truck and a reliable used rig isn’t just about upfront costs — it can also impact how much you pay for insurance. At Logrock, we help truckers navigate the ins and outs of insurance coverage, so you can make the best decision for your business. Let’s break down how your truck choice affects your premiums and what to consider before you buy.  

Why Your Truck Choice Matters for Insurance  

Insurance providers look at several factors when pricing your policy, and the truck itself plays a huge role. They assess things like:  

✅ Vehicle Value  

✅ Age and Mileage 

✅ Safety Features and Technology  

✅ Likelihood of Breakdowns or Costly Repairs

Whether you go new or used, each option has pros and cons. Let’s compare!  

The Case for Buying New  

A brand-new truck comes with cutting-edge safety tech and fewer immediate repair needs, which can work in your favor for insurance. But that higher sticker price can also drive up your insurance premiums.  

Insurance Benefits: 

✅ Advanced Safety Features: Collision avoidance, lane assist, and dash cams can qualify you for discounts.  

✅ Lower Risk of Breakdowns: Newer trucks are less likely to need expensive repairs, reducing the chance of claims.  

✅ Warranty Coverage: Manufacturer warranties can ease repair costs, which insurers may consider when pricing policies.  

Insurance Drawbacks:  

✅ Higher Replacement Costs: Since the truck is worth more, insurance payouts (and your premiums) will be higher.  

✅ Comprehensive & Collision Coverage Costs: You’ll likely want full coverage to protect your investment, which adds to your insurance bill.  

The Case for Buying Used  

A well-maintained used truck can save you money upfront and lower your insurance premiums — but it may come with hidden risks insurers will factor into your rates.  

Insurance Benefits:  

✅ Lower Vehicle Value: Since the truck costs less, your collision and comprehensive coverage will also be cheaper.  

✅ Proven Performance: A truck with a clean maintenance history can still be a safe, reliable choice at a lower cost.  

Insurance Drawbacks: 

✅ Higher Breakdown Risk: Older trucks are more prone to mechanical failures, which could lead to more claims.  

✅ Outdated Safety Tech: If your truck lacks modern safety features, you might miss out on valuable discounts.  

Which Option Is Right for You?  

The best choice depends on your business goals, budget, and risk tolerance. If you can afford higher premiums and want the peace of mind that comes with a new, tech-packed truck, that might be your best bet. But if saving on upfront costs and insurance is your priority, a well-maintained used truck could be the smarter move.  

Logrock Helps You Find the Right Coverage Either Way  

Whether you go new or used, Logrock can help you build a policy that fits your rig and your budget. We specialize in trucking insurance – we’ll guide you through coverage options and hunt down every possible discount.  

Get a Personalized Truck Insurance Quote Today and contact Logrock!

Keep your business rolling no matter what you drive!  

Tags

Written by

Daniel Summers
daniel.summers@logrock.com
My goal is simple: Help people start trucking companies, and keep them rolling. With my experience in transportation, I quickly decided to specialize in trucking insurance. It’s much more my speed and comfort zone: demanding, hectic, stressful…all the necessary ingredients to maintain my interests.
Share this article

Posted by

Daniel Summers
My goal is simple: Help people start trucking companies, and keep them rolling. With my experience in transportation, I quickly decided to specialize in trucking insurance. It’s much more my speed and comfort zone: demanding, hectic, stressful…all the necessary ingredients to maintain my interests.

Related Reading

Female Trucking Pioneers: Breaking Road Barriers
Daniel Summers
Loss Prevention Strategy for Trucking Insurance Clients‬
Nicholas Slahta
Accident Checklist: What to Do (and Not Do) to Protect Your Insurance Rates
Daniel Summers
Need Insurance?

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Stop Overpaying for Truck Insurance

Get quotes in a minute. Most truckers save $200+/month.

Join 5,000+ Truckers Saving on Insurance

Average savings: $2,400/year. See what we can find for you.

Tired of Shopping Around for Quotes?

One application gets you the best rates. We do the work.

logrock Blog

Related Posts
4 min

Start Your Trucking Company: FMCSA Authority Prep Guide

Thinking about hitting the road with your own trucking company? This guide is your no-nonsense roadmap to getting your FMCSA authority without hitting any bumps. We'll walk you through the essential prep work, from figuring out those hefty insurance costs and picking the right business structure like an LLC, to setting up your business addresses and handling the flood of calls and emails that come with starting up. You'll learn how to keep your personal life separate, manage your communications like a pro, and what to look out for when the FMCSA comes calling for your new entrant audit. This isn't just theory; it's practical, actionable advice to help you build a solid foundation, stay compliant, and get your wheels turning smoothly. Don't just hope for the best; prepare for success.
Daniel Summers
3 min

DOT Record & Truck Insurance: Clean Record, Lower Rates

Learn how your DOT record impacts truck insurance premiums. Discover actionable strategies to maintain a clean DOT record, reduce risk, and save money on commercial truck insurance.
Daniel Summers
3 min

Trucking Insurance 101: What Coverage Do You Really Need?

Daniel Summers