Tender Rejection Rate: What 13.9% Means for Carriers

Tender Rejection Rate: What 13.9% Means for Carriers
Check a truck insurance availability with LogRock

13 min read

A tender rejection rate shows how often carriers turn down contract freight offered by shippers. For an owner-operator, a 13.9% reading can point to tighter usable capacity—even when overall freight volume looks soft—but it doesn’t promise your next load will pay more.

What Tender Rejection Rate Means in Plain English#

Tender rejection rate is the percentage of electronically tendered contract loads that carriers decline. It is mainly a shipper-facing measure of whether contracted capacity is accepting freight through a routing guide, not a scorecard for one owner-operator or one broker relationship.

A tender is a shipper’s offer of a contracted load#

A freight tender is a shipper’s offer of a load to a carrier under an agreed contract arrangement. The carrier can accept it, reject it, or sometimes let the offer expire based on the system and shipper process.

A carrier might reject a tender because the truck is not in position, the appointment timing does not work, or the equipment does not fit. The carrier may also see a better reload opportunity elsewhere or decide the offered rate does not cover the real cost of running that lane.

A rejection is not the same as a declined carrier packet#

A market tender rejection happens when a carrier declines a specific contract load. That is different from a broker rejecting—or holding up—a carrier onboarding packet because something is missing or does not match.

For example, a broker may need a current certificate of insurance, W-9, USDOT number, MC number, or authority information before it can dispatch you. A tender-rejection index does not tell you whether your paperwork will clear onboarding.

Check a truck insurance availability with LogRock

How the Rate Is Calculated and Why Routing Guides Matter#

Tender rejection rate is calculated by dividing rejected tenders by total tenders and multiplying by 100. The number helps show whether contracted carriers are broadly accepting shipper freight, but its real value comes from watching the trend over time rather than judging one load or one day.

The basic tender rejection formula#

The formula is straightforward:

Rejected tenders ÷ total tenders × 100 = tender rejection rate

If carriers reject roughly 14 out of every 100 tracked contract tenders, the rejection rate is about 14%. That does not mean 14% of all freight is unavailable, and it does not mean every carrier is rejecting loads for the same reason.

What happens after a carrier declines a tender#

A routing guide is the shipper’s ordered list of contracted carriers to contact for a load. When the first carrier says no, the shipper may tender the freight to the next carrier, adjust the offer, or move the load into the spot market.

Repeated rejections can reveal that a shipper’s contract rate no longer matches available capacity on that lane. They can also show that capacity exists on paper but is not usable at the pickup time, in the right location, or with the right equipment.

Index providers do not all count tenders in exactly the same way. Before comparing readings, understand the provider’s methodology, covered freight, timing, and whether the data is national or segmented.

A single rejected load may be about a late appointment or a driver needing to get home. A sustained rise across many tenders is more likely to show a wider capacity shift.

What a 13.9% Tender Rejection Rate Signals#

A 13.9% tender rejection rate suggests carriers are declining a meaningful share of tracked contract freight, above the commonly described balanced-market reference range of 5% to 7%. It can indicate tighter or more selective capacity, though the meaning still changes by lane, equipment type, season, and data source.

A 5% to 7% range is a useful reference point, not a universal rule. A dry-van lane with easy reloads may behave differently from a seasonal reefer market, a flatbed lane affected by weather, or specialized freight with limited equipment.

At 13.9%, roughly 14 of every 100 tracked contract tenders are being declined in the measured market. That can mean carriers have fewer trucks available, have better options, or cannot make the operational timing work.

Why 13.9% is above a balanced 5% to 7% range#

When rejections sit near the balanced range, contracted carriers are generally accepting enough freight for routing guides to work without much stress. A move toward 13.9% means more loads are rolling past the first contracted option.

That can put pressure on shippers and brokers to find backup capacity. It may also push more freight toward the spot market when routing-guide options fail.

How tight capacity can coexist with weaker freight volume#

Soft freight volume does not automatically mean plenty of trucks are usable everywhere. Trucks can leave the market, carriers can avoid weak lanes, and freight can bunch into a few days, regions, or shipper locations.

Holiday schedules, weather, produce seasons, and regional demand surges can tighten a specific area even while national volume remains muted. This is why truckload tender rejection signals need lane-level context before they guide a business decision.

Why a market signal is not a guaranteed rate increase#

Higher rejections can lead spot-market pricing higher before contract rates catch up. But they do not guarantee more freight, better rates, or stronger margins for your truck.

Your result still depends on fuel, deadhead, detention risk, equipment demand, reload options, and the offer in front of you. A hot national headline cannot rescue an unprofitable lane.

Why Carriers Reject Freight Tenders#

Carriers reject freight tenders for practical operating reasons: truck position, equipment fit, pickup timing, lane economics, and load requirements. While a better-paying alternative can be part of the decision, many rejections happen because accepting the load would create a scheduling problem or a bad next move.

Truck position and equipment mismatch#

A carrier may have no truck near the pickup, or the available truck may be wrong for the freight. Dry vans, reefers, flatbeds, and specialized equipment do not move interchangeably.

Even when the equipment matches, the truck may be committed to another appointment, a home-time plan, maintenance, or a reload that makes more operational sense. Distance matters because long deadhead can erase a seemingly workable rate.

Short lead times and freight-volume bunching#

Short-notice tenders are harder to cover because trucks are already planned. Freight-volume bunching—when many loads need pickup at the same time—can create temporary capacity pressure without a broad increase in national freight demand.

Holidays, storms, produce harvests, and shipper surges often create these pockets. A rejection spike around those events may be real, but it may not last.

Lane economics and market volatility#

A carrier can reject a load because the rate-to-cost math does not work. That includes fuel, tolls, deadhead, driver time, dwell exposure, and the odds of finding a reload after delivery.

Market volatility makes this harder. A load that looks acceptable on the outbound leg can become a poor decision if the destination has weak reload demand.

Unclear load details or restrictive requirements#

Unclear commodity details, strict appointment windows, unusual securement needs, detention terms, or difficult facilities can also drive rejections. These are operational decisions, not necessarily a carrier “holding out” for more money.

For owner-operators, the best response is to price the full trip—not just the loaded miles.

How Owner-Operators Should Read Tender Rejection Data#

Owner-operators should treat tender rejection data as one market input, then test it against their equipment, lanes, lead time, reload options, and current spot conditions. A national number can help frame a rate conversation, but it cannot replace knowing what your truck can profitably do this week.

Start with your equipment type#

Ask whether the reading reflects freight similar to yours. A dry-van trend may not apply to reefer work, flatbed freight, or a specialized trailer setup.

Equipment availability can change quickly by region. A national index may hide a tight pocket of capacity near your pickup—or hide a weak market at your delivery point.

Check your lanes before the national number#

Look at your actual origin and destination, not just a national chart. Consider how far you must deadhead to pickup, what reloads exist after delivery, and whether the destination regularly creates dwell or empty miles.

A high rejection rate matters more if it lines up with strong demand in your preferred lanes. It matters less if your truck is positioned where freight remains loose.

Compare lead time and spot-market activity#

Short lead time often increases rejection risk because fewer carriers can reposition in time. Compare the tender trend with available spot loads, posted rates, pickup dates, and the number of realistic reloads.

Track direction over several weeks instead of reacting to one daily reading. Rising rejections may support a more disciplined rate conversation, but they do not eliminate the need to know your cost per mile and break-even point.

If you are getting ready to run under your own authority, market opportunity can disappear fast when onboarding paperwork is not ready.

Use the rate as one input, not a dispatch plan#

Use tender data to ask better questions: Is capacity tightening on my lanes? Are reloads improving? Is this offer covering the whole trip? Is the customer asking for a short-notice pickup?

Do not use it as a reason to take a bad load or turn down reliable freight without a replacement plan. Your truck’s revenue comes from profitable execution, not from predicting a chart perfectly.

What Tender Rejection Rate Does Not Tell You#

Tender rejection rate does not guarantee that your next load pays more, that freight is strong in every market, or that a broker will approve your carrier packet. It measures market-level contract-load acceptance, while your ability to book freight also depends on authority, documents, insurance, and a broker’s requirements.

It does not guarantee your next load pays more#

A rising index can signal more pressure on contracted capacity, but your offered rate may still be weak. A better gross rate can also produce a worse trip if it adds deadhead, dwell, tolls, or an empty reposition afterward.

The number says nothing about your exact operating cost. Price each load based on the work required and the realistic next load.

It does not prove freight is strong in every market#

National freight conditions can be soft while particular regions, days, commodities, or equipment types tighten. The reverse is also true: a strong national trend does not ensure your destination has good reloads.

Check the freight that matches your truck and lane plan. Broad data is context, not a substitute for dispatch facts.

It is not an insurance or authority approval signal#

A high tender rejection rate does not make a broker accept an expired certificate of insurance or incomplete carrier packet. Keep your legal business name consistent across your authority, W-9, insurance documents, and broker setup.

Motor carriers and freight counterparties can review public carrier identification, authority, and safety information through the FMCSA’s SAFER System. Covered motor carriers also have federal financial-responsibility obligations under 49 CFR Part 387, which are separate from market-capacity indicators.

It does not replace checking broker and shipper requirements#

Keep your active operating authority where required, USDOT number, MC number, W-9, certificate of insurance, and required FMCSA filings current. Review FMCSA compliance basics before assuming your authority is ready for a new booking.

Brokers may also ask for documentation beyond what an index can measure. Review the motor carrier filings that can affect whether your operation is ready to haul.

A Quick Tender Rejection Checklist for Carriers#

Use tender rejection data to support a disciplined load decision, not to replace one. Confirm what the index measures, compare its trend over time, narrow it to your equipment and lane where possible, then price the actual trip using your operating costs and reload outlook.

Before using the number in a rate conversation#

Run through these questions:

  • Does the index source cover freight relevant to my equipment?
  • Is the rejection trend rising or falling over several weeks?
  • What are current spot loads and reloads doing on my lanes?
  • How much deadhead, dwell risk, fuel, and time does this load add?
  • Does the offered rate work after the full-trip costs?

When rejection rates are rising#

Keep your carrier packet and insurance documents current so you can respond when good opportunities appear. Do not assume every load should be accepted at any price, and do not assume every broker will pay more just because an index rose.

When rejection rates are falling#

Focus on profitable lanes, reliable reloads, and customers with workable operations. Falling rejections can mean more available capacity, but headlines should not override your own lane data and cost discipline.

For help understanding the commercial trucking insurance requirements and filings brokers commonly request,

Frequently Asked Questions#

What are tender rejection rates?

Tender rejection rates show the percentage of electronically tendered contract loads that carriers decline. In truckload freight, a shipper typically sends a load through its routing guide, and each decline may send that load to another contracted carrier or eventually to the spot market. A rising rejection rate can signal tighter or more selective capacity, while a falling rate can suggest carriers are accepting more contract freight. Use the trend as a market signal, not a guarantee that your truck will get more loads or a higher rate.

What are the expected freight rates in 2026?

No single freight-rate forecast applies to every owner-operator in 2026. Rates can vary sharply by equipment type, origin, destination, pickup lead time, season, fuel cost, available capacity, deadhead, and reload prospects. Instead of relying on a national forecast, check current conditions on the lanes you actually run and compare them with your operating costs. Tender rejection trends can provide useful context, but spot-market activity and the full-trip economics of a specific load matter more to your bottom line.

What is the meaning of rejection rate?

A rejection rate is the portion of offers, requests, or submissions that people decline. In truckload freight, the term usually means the share of shipper contract tenders that carriers reject. For example, a 13.9% tender rejection rate means about 14 out of every 100 tracked tenders were declined in the measured data set. It does not mean a broker rejected 13.9% of carrier packets, insurance certificates, or authority applications. Context matters because the metric measures market acceptance of loads.

Is the freight market slow right now?

The freight market can be soft overall while certain lanes or equipment segments are tight. To assess conditions, look at freight volume, tender rejection trends, available trucks, spot-load activity, pickup lead times, and reload options on your actual lanes. A national number alone cannot tell you whether your next dry-van, reefer, or flatbed load will be profitable. If volume is weak but rejection rates rise, it may mean capacity has left the market or freight is concentrated in certain regions or time windows.

Check a truck insurance availability with LogRock

Tags

Written by

Daniel Summers
daniel@logrock.com
My goal is simple: help people start trucking companies and keep them rolling. With years of experience in the transportation industry, I chose to specialize in commercial trucking insurance, a niche I know inside and out. From helping new owner-operators get the right coverage to supporting established fleets with their insurance needs, this work is my comfort zone: demanding, fast-paced, and never boring, exactly what keeps me passionate about serving the commercial trucking community.
Share this article

Posted by

Daniel Summers
My goal is simple: help people start trucking companies and keep them rolling. With years of experience in the transportation industry, I chose to specialize in commercial trucking insurance, a niche I know inside and out. From helping new owner-operators get the right coverage to supporting established fleets with their insurance needs, this work is my comfort zone: demanding, fast-paced, and never boring, exactly what keeps me passionate about serving the commercial trucking community.

Related Reading

Van Insurance Comparison (2026): Compare Costs, Coverage & Companies
Daniel Summers
Semi Trucking Insurance Companies in Tennessee: Compare
Daniel Summers
Dry Van Truck Insurance Idaho: Coverage, Costs and Rules
Daniel Summers
Need Insurance?

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Stop Overpaying for Truck Insurance

Get quotes in a minute. Most truckers save $200+/month.

Join 5,000+ Truckers Saving on Insurance

Average savings: $2,400/year. See what we can find for you.

Tired of Shopping Around for Quotes?

One application gets you the best rates. We do the work.

logrock Blog

Related Posts
2 min

Start Your Trucking Company: 6 Steps to Prep Your FMCSA Authority Application

Thinking about hitting the road with your own trucking company? This guide is your no-nonsense roadmap to getting your FMCSA authority without hitting any bumps. We'll walk you through the essential prep work, from figuring out those hefty insurance costs and picking the right business structure like an LLC, to setting up your business addresses and handling the flood of calls and emails that come with starting up. You'll learn how to keep your personal life separate, manage your communications like a pro, and what to look out for when the FMCSA comes calling for your new entrant audit. This isn't just theory; it's practical, actionable advice to help you build a solid foundation, stay compliant, and get your wheels turning smoothly. Don't just hope for the best; prepare for success.
Daniel Summers
dot record
12 min

DOT Record and Trucking Insurance: How It Affects Rates

Learn how your DOT record impacts truck insurance premiums. Discover actionable strategies to maintain a clean DOT record, reduce risk, and save money on commercial truck insurance.
Daniel Summers
2 min

Trucking Insurance 101: 6 Coverages for Owner-Operators

Daniel Summers